Andrew Penny, November 10 2026

Web Marketing is SO Last Year!

Imagine you've spent 20 years building a company that makes the best widgets in North America.

Your customers love you. Your reputation is excellent. Your website is beautiful. You've invested a fortune in SEO, Google Ads and content marketing.

Someone asks ChatGPT, "Who makes the best widgets in North America?"It recommends three of your competitors.

Oops!

What does AI think of YOUR company?

It's frightening how often I use AI:

In almost every one of these conversations, AI has an opportunity to recommend a product, service or supplier. And not just based on the question I'm asking, but potentially on everything it knows about me from our previous conversations.

Think about that.

For the last 30 years, we've spent billions trying to get customers to visit our websites.

Now we're building a world in which they may never need to.

Keywords, page titles, Google Ads, beautifully handcrafted content and endless "Top 10" lists. They're not disappearing, but the rules are changing.

Why search for results when you can AI for answers?

"Where should I buy [insert incredibly detailed requirement] in WesternCanada?"

Instead of sorting through a page of sponsored results and websites, buyers can get an answer tailored to their exact requirements, complete with recommendations, comparisons and cautions.

They have something approaching the collective wisdom of the world at their fingertips.

The power has shifted from the seller, trying desperately to be found, to the buyer, who can ask practically anything.

And here's the interesting part.

AI doesn't necessarily believe what you say about yourself.

Sure, it can examine your website. But it can also draw on Better Business Bureau reports, customer reviews, court proceedings, industry publications, competitor websites, independent rankings, certifications and just about anything else available digitally.

It might tell your prospective customer that your service is relatively new and unproven, that there have been complaints about your support, or that recent management changes could cause disruption.

Oops!

Or, perhaps worse, it might not mention you at all.

You may genuinely be the best at what you do. But if AI can't find credible evidence of that expertise, why would it recommend you?

Here's an interesting exercise. Ask your favourite AI assistant: "Who is the best supplier of [whatever you sell] for [your ideal customer]?"

Do you appear? What does it say about you? Who does it recommend instead?

Now ask your management team to do the same thing using their own AI assistants, accounts and wording.

You'll probably get different answers. That's part of the point.

So, if you're not happy with what you find, what are you going to do about it?

TWO THINGS:

THING ONE – DON'T BE A GENERALIST.

I've been saying this for decades. Pick a lane.

Be the world's expert in something.

No one believes you're the best at everything. If you're a small company, find something you do exceptionally well, give it a name and own it. If you're a larger firm, have each product area do the same for itself.

The smaller and tighter the specialization, the better.

Think about it from the buyer's perspective.

If someone asks AI for the best manufacturer of gaskets, there are hundreds of possible answers.

But what if they ask for the best manufacturer of high-temperature gaskets for small marine diesel engines?

That's a very different question.

And if that's precisely what you're brilliant at, wouldn't you like AI to know?

You don't have to be the biggest. You have to be the best answer to the right question.

THING TWO – KNOW YOUR STUFF, AND TELL PEOPLE ABOUT IT.

I call this Thought Leadership.

AI can examine product specifications and service descriptions, but it can also look for evidence that you actually know what you're talking about.

That sort of credibility is hard to fake. It takes time to establish and can be enormously powerful.

And if you really are the best at what you do, you probably already have the information. You just need to tell people about it.

Showcase your industry knowledge, specialized capabilities, innovation, problem-solving skills and successful customer applications.

Share insights on emerging trends, new technologies, regulatory changes, sustainability, market dynamics and evolving customer needs.

Publish it. Discuss it. Present it. Get others talking about it.

Make your expertise visible, accessible and verifiable.

Remember, Thought Leadership is NOT selling.

It's not about your product - it’s how and why you design and make your product the way you do. Its demonstrating who you are and what you know, so the right people can decide whether they trust you and want to do business with you.

And increasingly, those people are asking AI before they ask you.

For decades, marketing has been about getting found.

Increasingly, it's also about being worthy of being found.

You can't force AI to say nice things about your company. But you can give it some very good reasons to.

As The Who would say: Who are you? Who, who? Who, who?

Your prospective customers really do want to know.


And now, so does their AI.

Andrew

Written by

Andrew Penny

Tags

Previous The Stuff in the Middle
Next The Value of What You Don't Know